Nagrand Slam?

Exactly!

What? Why? Where’s the Anomaly here?

Lol that was more or less a blind guess because I couldn't think of another Standard card that summons 4 minions that attack immediately (I deduced these points from the hints).

Hm. There is Big Ol' Whelp with 5 attack for Billy; Illidari Felblade for Tommy; Cosmic Anomaly for Johnny; and the last one went to face (which hinted at a Hunter card?).

It makes sense I guess, but the hints were dearly needed.

Indeed, that's the right order, the last part of the riddle (face to face) was to point out why it survived, that hunter is known to be the "face" class just adds flavor to it.

But then why did you say that Johnny WAS the Anomaly?

Quote From Fedrion

Nope, nope and nope.

Anomaly is the word, but not that anomaly.

Asides from that, stop thinking too much in elementals.

 

Edit: Didn't see the post of @anchorm4n it is Cosmic Anomaly, not the final answer but part of the riddle nonetheless. 

Never said it was the card, I said it was tied to the final answer, which it is.

But you said “Johnny was an anomaly, he barely survived”... oh whatever, poetic license I suppose 

Yeah, I can't argue that, I suppose I should have phrased it "For Johnny was an anomaly...", fair point.

But it would have lost the rhythm of the names first.

Anyways, here's the next riddle. I have no idea if this is too hard but I've wanted to try something like this for a while.

taozftha fsypeicdvj

Cryptogram solver says this corresponds to “ASHTRAYS REDOUBLING”

... I’m guessing it’s not a cryptogram  

This is probably wrong, but I'm going to guess Kathrena Winterwisp because it's the correct number of letters.

It's not Kathrena and after having read the wiki I'm not sure if it's a cryptogram to be honest. :D

Hint: It's a card name and the number of letters in both words has not been changed. I would appreciate it if you would try to break the code instead of brute force guessing cards that have a matching number of letters though. 

Jeez Louise, this game lately ...

Come on, it's nice to try something new from time to time. If it proves to be too hard, I'll give major hints.

Here's something that might be helpful: the seventh and the eighth letter in the second word are the same.

Ok, if we shift the first letter back by one, the second by two, the third by three, and so on, we get Sylvanas Windrunner.

Glad that got settled fast. Dial it back big-brains XD

Ah, nice... a crypto-cryptogram ^^

That's right NerdyMcNerd! You're next :-)

Okey dokey, I've had this idea for a little while, it might be way to easy or hard but here goes:

Dr Boom wants to combine these mixed up minions, it's a pity one of them isn't a mech.

1) Wrong-Lot

2) Shine Dim Old Bite

3) Grated Tummy

4) In Footy Palace

5) Stage Leerer