I mean, that's your opinion and I totally get it! I was personally really happy with it (as were many other people), but if you don't like it, that's great! Just, no hard feelings, OK?
Also, I'd love to hear your feedback so I could improve my card-making! What in particular made you dislike it?
Well, I just found out someone submitted a card extremely similar to mine. Guess it's back to the drawing board! No hard feelings to whoever submitted it though, I guess I should've been more confident about it lmao.
Feedback regarding my ideas has been a little all over the place, in regards to what people prefer. With that in mind, I came up with something else lol
Show Spoiler
Edwin VanCleef will have his revolution, and the Alliance will tremble before the might of the Common people!
If you prefer an old idea from Page 1, just let me know :)
You don't need the "combo" on the Hero Power. If your minion has summoning sickness then it probably means you played it from your hand and have the combo ready to trigger.
You're probably right: I just included it as a catch-all in case something down the line existed to bring up the issue, like a Start of Turn summoning effect or whatever. Al'ar, for example, or pulling Waxadred's Candle/Spider Ambush!.
If it bugs people I'll remove it.
I personally see no issue with it, but that's just me. Then again, I love seeing weird stuff when it comes to things like Hero Powers, and you rarely see Combo in one, if at all.
Alright, I've got a free moment so let's give out some FEEDBACK!
As always, this will most likely be pretty shit, but if it helps you, that's all I care about.
Show Spoiler
Demonxz95 - I really like this, but it's obviously a little shaky. Some combos are useless/detrimental and some are ludicrously strong. Also, why not make this Legendary? You'd never run more than one of this in a deck anyway, right?
Linkblade91 - My favourite is probably To The Arena. The effect is really cool, especially because it mirrors to your opponent. Blackhand is perhaps a little bit strong and the Hunter one just doesn't excite me at all, sorry.
Inconspicuosaurus - It's pretty good on paper, but how much does the HP cost? Cause 2 might be a little too cheap, I think making it 3 would be optimal.
MenacingBagel - It's so overpowered and stupid. I secretly love it. But yeah, maybe come up with something a little more… low-key. (Any Hero Power that costs 8 freaking mana might be a tad too much).
Dermostatic - I actually like it tbh. It's pretty simple but works well for Treant Druid which is still in a rough place.
KANSAS - As an aura, it's quite well balanced! It's kinda like a 3-mana War Axe that counts as a minion but has the potential to be much more deadly than that.
Tox - I see no problem with the wording of this. As for the balance… maybe make it cost a little more and tweak the stats accordingly. I think 3-mana is a little too low to come up with that sort of swing in later turns.
Pokeniner - Pre AOO, I would've called this way too strong. But now that Metamorphasis exists, I'd say it's fine. Maybe knock it down to 2 uses if you feel the need, but I think 3 would be OK.
Shaveyou - I love this card! No complaints here!
Meisterz39 - I reckon you should change the Windfury to 'this turn only'. Cause yeah, this could be really swingy otherwise. Also Whirlwind Tempest says hi!
MurlocAggroB - This is just a very solid card. Nothing incredible, but nothing terrible. It's fairly solid.
DescentOfDragonsOP - I like the idea of Overload on a Hero Power, giving more support to a somewhat useless archetype. But 4 damage is too much. I think 3 is much better.
TheHoax91 - Prophet Zul is really damn cool. I don't think you can circumvent the wordiness, but the effect is so damn cool. A'dal is pretty good, though it has huge swing potential. Rune of Destruction is way too gimmicky to ever be useable.
Overall, very well done so far! This one is shaping out to be very, very interesting...
Yeah, that's a fair point. Do you reckon it would be better if I made it friendly minions only? Give some love to Silence Priest without completely breaking the game?
I think if it were 1 mana and only hit friendly minions it would be awesome
Yup, made the change. Already that looks a lot better, thanks
Yeah, that's a fair point. Do you reckon it would be better if I made it friendly minions only? Give some love to Silence Priest without completely breaking the game?
Very quick idea I came up with. Is the HP too strong at 1-mana? (Also yes, it's the card art for Purify, that's a place-holder while I create some more ideas)
I doubt this will be my submission unless I get really stuck, but this is just a starting idea.
Edit: Changed the effect to 'Silence a friendly minion' so that the game doesn't break due to this one card... as if that hasn't happened before lmao.
This one is pretty creative, so I probably won't have an idea I'm happy with for a while... I'll try and give feedback once a couple of cards have piled up in the meantime though.
Totally intended to go with the competition's title. The token is just simply one example of what you can do.
Just one question - what would happen with HPs that cancel each other out, like Mage and Priest. Do you choose two different targets, or does the target suffer both effects
I wonder if I would've done better if I submitted my 1 mana version instead.
Honestly, I gave your card 5-stars. I don't think it was your fault that it didn't do well, it's just the competition this time around was really harsh. I really liked your card though, if that matters at all
Hey, I accidentally uploaded my card portrait instead of my card. Is it somehow possible to change the image?
This was the card I wanted to post:
Thanks in advance for the help
Sadly, there is currently no way to edit or revoke a submission and you will most likely be disqualified this round. Sorry man, I can't do much for you..
This is... a strange one, to be sure! I'm kinda lost, but I'll see what works!
Good luck to you all! I hope this theme was enjoyable, I saw some great cards
Kind of sad that for my prompt I am incredibly busy for Day 1. I'll get something happening tomorrow, along with some feedback.
I hope you guys enjoy this theme btw!
I mean, that's your opinion and I totally get it! I was personally really happy with it (as were many other people), but if you don't like it, that's great! Just, no hard feelings, OK?
Also, I'd love to hear your feedback so I could improve my card-making! What in particular made you dislike it?
Idea #2! Any thoughts?
Well, I just found out someone submitted a card extremely similar to mine. Guess it's back to the drawing board! No hard feelings to whoever submitted it though, I guess I should've been more confident about it lmao.
I personally see no issue with it, but that's just me. Then again, I love seeing weird stuff when it comes to things like Hero Powers, and you rarely see Combo in one, if at all.
Oh. That's quite terrifying actually. I honestly like that better tbh, thanks for the call
Alright, I've got a free moment so let's give out some FEEDBACK!
As always, this will most likely be pretty shit, but if it helps you, that's all I care about.
Demonxz95 - I really like this, but it's obviously a little shaky. Some combos are useless/detrimental and some are ludicrously strong. Also, why not make this Legendary? You'd never run more than one of this in a deck anyway, right?
Linkblade91 - My favourite is probably To The Arena. The effect is really cool, especially because it mirrors to your opponent. Blackhand is perhaps a little bit strong and the Hunter one just doesn't excite me at all, sorry.
Inconspicuosaurus - It's pretty good on paper, but how much does the HP cost? Cause 2 might be a little too cheap, I think making it 3 would be optimal.
MenacingBagel - It's so overpowered and stupid. I secretly love it. But yeah, maybe come up with something a little more… low-key. (Any Hero Power that costs 8 freaking mana might be a tad too much).
Dermostatic - I actually like it tbh. It's pretty simple but works well for Treant Druid which is still in a rough place.
KANSAS - As an aura, it's quite well balanced! It's kinda like a 3-mana War Axe that counts as a minion but has the potential to be much more deadly than that.
Tox - I see no problem with the wording of this. As for the balance… maybe make it cost a little more and tweak the stats accordingly. I think 3-mana is a little too low to come up with that sort of swing in later turns.
Pokeniner - Pre AOO, I would've called this way too strong. But now that Metamorphasis exists, I'd say it's fine. Maybe knock it down to 2 uses if you feel the need, but I think 3 would be OK.
Shaveyou - I love this card! No complaints here!
Meisterz39 - I reckon you should change the Windfury to 'this turn only'. Cause yeah, this could be really swingy otherwise. Also Whirlwind Tempest says hi!
MurlocAggroB - This is just a very solid card. Nothing incredible, but nothing terrible. It's fairly solid.
DescentOfDragonsOP - I like the idea of Overload on a Hero Power, giving more support to a somewhat useless archetype. But 4 damage is too much. I think 3 is much better.
TheHoax91 - Prophet Zul is really damn cool. I don't think you can circumvent the wordiness, but the effect is so damn cool. A'dal is pretty good, though it has huge swing potential. Rune of Destruction is way too gimmicky to ever be useable.
Overall, very well done so far! This one is shaping out to be very, very interesting...
Yup, made the change. Already that looks a lot better, thanks
Yeah, that's a fair point. Do you reckon it would be better if I made it friendly minions only? Give some love to Silence Priest without completely breaking the game?
Very quick idea I came up with. Is the HP too strong at 1-mana? (Also yes, it's the card art for Purify, that's a place-holder while I create some more ideas)
I doubt this will be my submission unless I get really stuck, but this is just a starting idea.
Edit: Changed the effect to 'Silence a friendly minion' so that the game doesn't break due to this one card... as if that hasn't happened before lmao.
This one is pretty creative, so I probably won't have an idea I'm happy with for a while... I'll try and give feedback once a couple of cards have piled up in the meantime though.
Just one question - what would happen with HPs that cancel each other out, like Mage and Priest. Do you choose two different targets, or does the target suffer both effects
Well, that was a fun surprise to wake up too! I did not expect that tbh, but thanks!
Honestly, I gave your card 5-stars. I don't think it was your fault that it didn't do well, it's just the competition this time around was really harsh. I really liked your card though, if that matters at all
Good luck to everyone!
Holy shit I finally made it into the finals let's goooooooooo!
Good luck to everyone! I think this theme has the most 5-stars I've ever given, a lot of you did really good!
Sadly, there is currently no way to edit or revoke a submission and you will most likely be disqualified this round. Sorry man, I can't do much for you..