Wow. That was some great feedback, thanks a bunch guys! I think I’m gonna submit the 2-mana 4/4 with changed wording. Looking back, it felt more flavourful to the whole theme of the comp. Sorry to everyone who liked the 4-mana card, it was a really tough one in the end.
Again, another big thanks to you all and good luck in the comp! 💜
Oh man, as a Wild main, i loved this week's theme. Here's my first ideias, thoughts?
My favourite is definitely the Medivh set. Loatheb just seems weaker than the original, Yogg-Saron giving weapons feels a bit weird, and Patches' weapons should probably be a 1/3 so that it's never a dead weapon. But I'd just say stick with Medivh, that card is really good
A new idea to round out my trifecta! My favourite is probably Manastorm, but feedback on all three would be greatly appreciated! I'll try and give some of my own in a couple hours :)
I'm sure there will be many Gruul cards, so I'm probably gonna lab up some other stuff, but here's what I've got for now. Is it too simple for a Legendary?
OK, I've changed up the card a little. It's a bit cheaper and now only shuffles a copy into your opponent's deck. Again, the uses are kinda niche, but I feel like if it was printed people would experiment with it and I'm sure some meme deck would arrive.
Good luck to all the finalists! I was not happy with any of my ideas this time, so I didn't expect a great result. Let's hope next week works out better!
in my opinion this is a tricky one but heres what i submitted
heres the token card as well
This should really be changed to a 2-mana secret and toned down accordingly... messing with the prices completely goes against the theme of... you know, SECRETS.
Plus I personally would dock a star for poor grammar, sorry, I just can’t stand it..
EDIT: Nevermind, it seems you already submitted it. I would highly recommend coming here first, so that you can get some feedback. The card has a decent idea, it just needed some editing to make it work with the theme
little variation on the unofficial Elusive keyword. This can be targeted by spells and hero powers, but takes no damage from them. Polymorphs still work on them but things like Fireball does nothing.
I believe you forgot to put Taunt on this. But once you fix that up, this is a cool idea!
Wow. That was some great feedback, thanks a bunch guys! I think I’m gonna submit the 2-mana 4/4 with changed wording. Looking back, it felt more flavourful to the whole theme of the comp. Sorry to everyone who liked the 4-mana card, it was a really tough one in the end.
Again, another big thanks to you all and good luck in the comp! 💜
My favourite is definitely the Medivh set. Loatheb just seems weaker than the original, Yogg-Saron giving weapons feels a bit weird, and Patches' weapons should probably be a 1/3 so that it's never a dead weapon. But I'd just say stick with Medivh, that card is really good
Alright, I'm just gonna hone in on these two, thanks @Pokeniner!
Which one do you guys like better? I honestly cannot decide, I really like both.
A new idea to round out my trifecta! My favourite is probably Manastorm, but feedback on all three would be greatly appreciated! I'll try and give some of my own in a couple hours :)
I'm sure there will be many Gruul cards, so I'm probably gonna lab up some other stuff, but here's what I've got for now. Is it too simple for a Legendary?
Do tri-class cards count? Also, any other feedback on this would be nice. :)
Another lacklustre week for me here... good luck to all the finalists! I love most of the cards that made it in (I thought one was a bit weaker).
Good luck to everyone with the votes
This is great! I'd love to see more of these for each of the competitions. :)
OK, I've changed up the card a little. It's a bit cheaper and now only shuffles a copy into your opponent's deck. Again, the uses are kinda niche, but I feel like if it was printed people would experiment with it and I'm sure some meme deck would arrive.
Is this any better?
Alright, here's an idea I like much better! Do you think this is a bit overpowered?
The first thing that came to my mind when I saw this theme. I might lab out some more complex stuff, but I think this is a good starting point.
Good luck to all the finalists! I was not happy with any of my ideas this time, so I didn't expect a great result. Let's hope next week works out better!
Gonna be honest, completely forgot that card existed, thanks for the pointer
New idea! Yes, I know there was an Arena card called Smoke Bomb, but this was the best name I had at the time lmao.
This should really be changed to a 2-mana secret and toned down accordingly... messing with the prices completely goes against the theme of... you know, SECRETS.
Plus I personally would dock a star for poor grammar, sorry, I just can’t stand it..
EDIT: Nevermind, it seems you already submitted it. I would highly recommend coming here first, so that you can get some feedback. The card has a decent idea, it just needed some editing to make it work with the theme
Idea #1. What do you guys think?
Next:
I believe you forgot to put Taunt on this. But once you fix that up, this is a cool idea!
Finally, I think we're clear. Good stats, good flavour and good wording. Still up for feedback though.