When I think about it, the last two really are a stretch, and you got the first one right. HEAVY hint: the Dirty Rat part is about the card’s name, and the Totemic Surge part is about the art (whose clue can also be found in EVIL Totem
My question is: are Lackeys a set-specific mechanic? I mean, they are surely not evergreen, but they are used in three expansions. Also, are Razorpetals a mechanic that counts?
Lackeys are like Twinspell on that regard, and if Twinspell is allowed I don’t see why Lackeys wouldn’t. About the Razorpetals, I’m pretty confident it’s allowed since it’s very clearly something used only in Un'goro
Also, feedback:
Show Spoiler
Demonxz95
Show Spoiler
EW — 5/5. Nothing much to comment, just a neat card
linkblade91
Show Spoiler
RR — -1 star for balance (this is very much above the power level of other fragment cards, and on a class which has a 1 cost HP), so 4/5
Wailor
Show Spoiler
S-o-R — -1 star for aesthetics (should be a Beast), -1 star for balance (I think it’s pretty weak, the only range I see this being considered is 6 Mana for two 1/2s and 3 Adaptations, which isn’t very impressive), so 3/5
anchorm4n
Show Spoiler
Zev — 5/5. Seems alright and I don’t want to spend a lot of time thinking about it since I hate DH as a class lol
SSS - I believe Dormant isn’t a one expansion-only keyword, so this fails the prompt, 1/5
BloodMeFist
Show Spoiler
DM — -1(?) star for balance (as you said, it’s got some reaaal scary potential, so this is more out of caution than anything), so 4(5?)/5
DavnanKillder
Show Spoiler
SS — -1 star for idea (nothing very inventive, it’s not bad but not really finalist worthy), so 4/5
MP — -1 star for idea (IMO it’s just got bunch of effects going on without any actual reason to stack them all together), -1 star for balance (did anyone say Hunting Mastiff?), -1 star for aesthetics (Should be a “:” after Overkill instead of a “;”) so 2/5
EG — -1 star for aesthetics (art isn’t very hearthstone-esque), -1 star for idea (again, no real correlation between the effects on the card), -1 star for balance (compare to other 3/3/2 weapons like [Hearthstone Card (Eaglehorn Bow[/card) so 3/5
) Not Found]
Hordaki
Show Spoiler
KS — 5/5. Not terribly interesting to me for some reason, but nothing really wrong with it
PotM — 5/5. Love the flavor connection with Colossus of the Moon
ChickyChick
Show Spoiler
LE — -1 star for idea (just seems like an effect dump without a lot of thought put into it), so 4/5
KANSAS
Show Spoiler
Micro — -1 star for idea (Adapt just seems really out of place, and without it the card is just very bland), -1 star for aesthetics (should be a comma after Echo, not a period), so 3/5
Also also, would Awestruck Apprentice be better as a 1/1/3? That way you can benefit off the Inspire more easily
Just a note about your feedback @KANSAS, the cards are returned anyway, independently of whether the Greench died or not. Feedback of my own coming soon
Again, I really don’t see what’s unwritten here. The prompt was to make a card for a character not in standard, not to make a card for a character which has a card not in standard. It’s like saying evolve shaman is a wild archetype because some evolve shaman cards are no longer in standard
Still, I very much doubt it won’t be used in the future. Casts When Drawn also became a keyword in a specific xpac (don’t remember which) and has been used ever since
EDIT: changed it to this since my last card was way too similar to Throw Glaive. Yes, Spellburst and Inspire was done earlier, but this is a vastly different effect. I’ll try to come up with something even more original nonetheless
Flavor is that when inspired, she goes back to being as full of wonder as she was when she cast her first spell!
@anchorm4n I thought the flavor was pretty lacking honestly.
First off, that art was of a completely different character (and, well... you had the future Toki art for it, so not like there was no choice).
Second, the effect didn’t click at all with the flavor for me. Copying cards in your opponent’s deck is a well known Priest trope, and never once did it strike me in a time travel context
Oh I’m definitely enjoying it
lel
When I think about it, the last two really are a stretch, and you got the first one right. HEAVY hint: the Dirty Rat part is about the card’s name, and the Totemic Surge part is about the art (whose clue can also be found in EVIL Totem
Does “earn” in the earning 1000 Snowflakes bit mean “stored in your bank” or “even if you spent it”?
why don’t they show their requirement when you complete them? Been wondering that for a while now
No. Hint: this is an Incanter's Flow style riddle
Last Second Dinner news was over a YEAR ago?? Dammmn, talk about building hype
Nope
AMEN TO THAT
Lackeys are like Twinspell on that regard, and if Twinspell is allowed I don’t see why Lackeys wouldn’t. About the Razorpetals, I’m pretty confident it’s allowed since it’s very clearly something used only in Un'goro
Also, feedback:
Demonxz95
EW — 5/5. Nothing much to comment, just a neat card
linkblade91
RR — -1 star for balance (this is very much above the power level of other fragment cards, and on a class which has a 1 cost HP), so 4/5
Wailor
S-o-R — -1 star for aesthetics (should be a Beast), -1 star for balance (I think it’s pretty weak, the only range I see this being considered is 6 Mana for two 1/2s and 3 Adaptations, which isn’t very impressive), so 3/5
anchorm4n
Zev — 5/5. Seems alright and I don’t want to spend a lot of time thinking about it since I hate DH as a class lol
SSS - I believe Dormant isn’t a one expansion-only keyword, so this fails the prompt, 1/5
BloodMeFist
DM — -1(?) star for balance (as you said, it’s got some reaaal scary potential, so this is more out of caution than anything), so 4(5?)/5
DavnanKillder
SS — -1 star for idea (nothing very inventive, it’s not bad but not really finalist worthy), so 4/5
MP — -1 star for idea (IMO it’s just got bunch of effects going on without any actual reason to stack them all together), -1 star for balance (did anyone say Hunting Mastiff?), -1 star for aesthetics (Should be a “:” after Overkill instead of a “;”) so 2/5
EG — -1 star for aesthetics (art isn’t very hearthstone-esque), -1 star for idea (again, no real correlation between the effects on the card), -1 star for balance (compare to other 3/3/2 weapons like [Hearthstone Card (Eaglehorn Bow[/card) so 3/5
) Not Found]
Hordaki
KS — 5/5. Not terribly interesting to me for some reason, but nothing really wrong with it
PotM — 5/5. Love the flavor connection with Colossus of the Moon
ChickyChick
LE — -1 star for idea (just seems like an effect dump without a lot of thought put into it), so 4/5
KANSAS
Micro — -1 star for idea (Adapt just seems really out of place, and without it the card is just very bland), -1 star for aesthetics (should be a comma after Echo, not a period), so 3/5
Also also, would Awestruck Apprentice be better as a 1/1/3? That way you can benefit off the Inspire more easily
No
Just a note about your feedback @KANSAS, the cards are returned anyway, independently of whether the Greench died or not. Feedback of my own coming soon
Again, I really don’t see what’s unwritten here. The prompt was to make a card for a character not in standard, not to make a card for a character which has a card not in standard. It’s like saying evolve shaman is a wild archetype because some evolve shaman cards are no longer in standard
Still, I very much doubt it won’t be used in the future. Casts When Drawn also became a keyword in a specific xpac (don’t remember which) and has been used ever since
Pretty sure Dormant is an evergreen keyword
What do you get when you cross a SI:7 Agent, a Dirty Rat and a Totemic Surge?
“Returning the cards you stole? How generous ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)“
Does this count?
EDIT: changed it to this since my last card was way too similar to Throw Glaive. Yes, Spellburst and Inspire was done earlier, but this is a vastly different effect. I’ll try to come up with something even more original nonetheless
Flavor is that when inspired, she goes back to being as full of wonder as she was when she cast her first spell!
Dwarven Sharpshooter!
I’m not debating whether it’s going to get disqualified or not, I’m saying that I think it’s very clearly going against the idea of the prompt
@anchorm4n I thought the flavor was pretty lacking honestly.
First off, that art was of a completely different character (and, well... you had the future Toki art for it, so not like there was no choice).
Second, the effect didn’t click at all with the flavor for me. Copying cards in your opponent’s deck is a well known Priest trope, and never once did it strike me in a time travel context