I made a deck of 13 [[Costumed Entertainer]] and 2 [[Fishflinger]] just for kicks and got some crazy wins. You don’t need to limit yourself to 2 copies, so if you have 15 of something, have at it.
Thanks everyone for feedback! I’m sorry I haven’t given much this time, will do better next round. I’ve tinkered with my card and changed it out for an idea from one of my custom classes.
My first idea: Rogue/Hunter Secret! The art is not final, and I need to make the token still. The idea is if the first Hound kills the attacking minion, the 2nd won’t attack and will retain Stealth.
I picked some different art and a new name for my submission. Balance wise, I think it’s fine for Shaman to Coin or Lighting Bloom and get a 3-drop turn 1. Other classes can pull off crazier turn 1 plays. Plus Overload and terrible card draw limit their ability to push.
“He’s got nowhere to go but up! Unless he becomes a gnome. Or goblin. Or..”
KANSAS - If the Battlecry is duplicated, it will only kill with one of the pings, so it’ll only get 2 health. The doubled Battlecry just lets you kill 2-health targets. It’s a cute balanced card but not sure it will stand out much.
Mr. Rhapsody - Would this make all 3 Arcane Missiles hit the target, or just the first one? Cool card.
Arden - Love it. 2/1 or 1/2 statline might be fine, but I wouldn’t give it more than that, since the Companion has above average stats.
Nirast - A 1/2 and 1/1 on turn 1 is very strong, and it’s bonkers in an odd Paladin deck. There’s also no dude synergy in Scholomance so it’s not thematic.
Found some art I’m happy with for my card. I’m glad that people seem to like it! It’s a flexible card that can disrupt your opponents draw and can influence how you build your deck.
TheHoax - A 1 Mana 2/2 with an upside is far too strong. Make it 2 Mana or a 1/2 or something. I do like the disruption it gives
Feuerrabe - Your submission needs to affect your opponent’s deck. It can be a mirrored effect, though neither of your cards would work well that way. Cool ideas though.
Wailor - I agree that Johana’s much better art fits better with the card’s theme. I like it more than the Raven or the minor character.
anchorm4n - Mass Polymorph is a big no from me. I know the theme is to mess with decks, but that straight up destroys decks. The Gambler is a very complicated card, I’m not sure how it would be played or if anyone would ever play it.
My first idea: an impatient Old Gods cultist. He can set up your game winning combo, but be careful, because your opponent gets their biggest minion too. In the early game, this will be a dead draw for both players. Either way, the game will inevitable end soon.
Tricks of the Trade - Both versions trick your opponent into playing poorly to counter a Secret, only to become a new one next turn. I wasn’t sure if the “different classes” version was too good or not.
City Watch - Summon an Annoy-o-Tron after getting attacked to slow down aggro. If it survives, it’s also a great target for buffs or Magnetize
Thanks shaveyou. I did some more brainstorming and came up with this card. Not sure if it would be more balanced at (5) or (7) Mana, as there aren’t a ton of scary big taunts besides the Lich King, which can’t be run in an Odd deck anyway.
I’ve changed my original idea slightly to make it stronger but harder to cheat out (sorry Oaken Summons). Certain classes can still cheat it out if they devote their deck to it.
Ive also got a new idea: a big beefy Taunt that won’t save you if you are facing down Agro. Though I’m not sure if that would be enough of a downside for including in this comp.
Edit - upon further review, I think the Myrmidon is cool but not a good fit for this contest. Also to would probably be better as a smaller minion. I’ll submit Gurtogg
I made a deck of 13 [[Costumed Entertainer]] and 2 [[Fishflinger]] just for kicks and got some crazy wins. You don’t need to limit yourself to 2 copies, so if you have 15 of something, have at it.
Sadly my quests aren’t progressing at all
No because then you’d have a neutral card in your deck...
Demon hunter should be excluded because they only play class cards anyway, lol
Thanks everyone for feedback! I’m sorry I haven’t given much this time, will do better next round. I’ve tinkered with my card and changed it out for an idea from one of my custom classes.
I’ve changed my card, as the 2-class Secret had some issues with it. Let me know what you think! I’ll try to give feedback later.
My first idea: Rogue/Hunter Secret! The art is not final, and I need to make the token still. The idea is if the first Hound kills the attacking minion, the 2nd won’t attack and will retain Stealth.
I picked some different art and a new name for my submission. Balance wise, I think it’s fine for Shaman to Coin or Lighting Bloom and get a 3-drop turn 1. Other classes can pull off crazier turn 1 plays. Plus Overload and terrible card draw limit their ability to push.
“He’s got nowhere to go but up! Unless he becomes a gnome. Or goblin. Or..”
KANSAS - If the Battlecry is duplicated, it will only kill with one of the pings, so it’ll only get 2 health. The doubled Battlecry just lets you kill 2-health targets. It’s a cute balanced card but not sure it will stand out much.
Mr. Rhapsody - Would this make all 3 Arcane Missiles hit the target, or just the first one? Cool card.
Arden - Love it. 2/1 or 1/2 statline might be fine, but I wouldn’t give it more than that, since the Companion has above average stats.
Nirast - A 1/2 and 1/1 on turn 1 is very strong, and it’s bonkers in an odd Paladin deck. There’s also no dude synergy in Scholomance so it’s not thematic.
Yay, card contests! My first idea, and I’ll give some feedback later. Hope this isn’t too complicated for a Common 1-drop.
Replicating then art style of the Scholomance set might be difficult. Anyone know of any good sources
No more Renew > Renew > Renew > Renew > ...
Does this work with Shadow Visions too
No way to get her in the mobile store.0
I’ll try to think of something more interesting. Shaman have it easy this comp
Can we submit token legendaries like Thaddius or VOLTRON?
Found some art I’m happy with for my card. I’m glad that people seem to like it! It’s a flexible card that can disrupt your opponents draw and can influence how you build your deck.
TheHoax - A 1 Mana 2/2 with an upside is far too strong. Make it 2 Mana or a 1/2 or something. I do like the disruption it gives
Feuerrabe - Your submission needs to affect your opponent’s deck. It can be a mirrored effect, though neither of your cards would work well that way. Cool ideas though.
Wailor - I agree that Johana’s much better art fits better with the card’s theme. I like it more than the Raven or the minor character.
anchorm4n - Mass Polymorph is a big no from me. I know the theme is to mess with decks, but that straight up destroys decks. The Gambler is a very complicated card, I’m not sure how it would be played or if anyone would ever play it.
My first idea: an impatient Old Gods cultist. He can set up your game winning combo, but be careful, because your opponent gets their biggest minion too. In the early game, this will be a dead draw for both players. Either way, the game will inevitable end soon.
My initial ideas:
Tricks of the Trade - Both versions trick your opponent into playing poorly to counter a Secret, only to become a new one next turn. I wasn’t sure if the “different classes” version was too good or not.
City Watch - Summon an Annoy-o-Tron after getting attacked to slow down aggro. If it survives, it’s also a great target for buffs or Magnetize
Thanks shaveyou. I did some more brainstorming and came up with this card. Not sure if it would be more balanced at (5) or (7) Mana, as there aren’t a ton of scary big taunts besides the Lich King, which can’t be run in an Odd deck anyway.
I’ve got 2 ideas so far. One for a late-game Armor buff, the other a way to get some extra Taunts to finish the Quest and protect your face.
edit - I might rework Bone Armor to be on a Taunt minion instead
Make this a Bear and it’ll get 5 stars from me.
edit - Sinti is right. Make it draw a Taunt minion instead
I’ve changed my original idea slightly to make it stronger but harder to cheat out (sorry Oaken Summons). Certain classes can still cheat it out if they devote their deck to it.
Ive also got a new idea: a big beefy Taunt that won’t save you if you are facing down Agro. Though I’m not sure if that would be enough of a downside for including in this comp.
Edit - upon further review, I think the Myrmidon is cool but not a good fit for this contest. Also to would probably be better as a smaller minion. I’ll submit Gurtogg