Last minute thought. Do not think Refreshing springwater is going to get nerfed. At 5 mana (except with no minion mage) it becomes horrible with 1 minion drawn... Better to play the classic 3 mana draw 2 card
Ok, but the problem is with it in no minion mage...
The first one is impossible to answer, as not even team 5 knows. As for the second one it probably depends entirely on warcraft lore. Other classes might have similar mechanics, but I doubt that other classes that don't get sigils in WoW would get them in Hearthstone.
@Ilphelkiir Spore Channeler seem way too good at 1 mana since it create insane swing turns for such cheap cost, especially since all of the Rogue Poison cost 2 or less. I think putting it at a 2 mana 3/2 / 2/3 is better compare to Radiant Elemental and Sorcerer Apprentice.
The reason I put it at 1 mana is because of Sorcerer's Apprentice and Radiant Elemental. Those two cards are unrestricted in the types of cards they can discount, meanwhile Spore Channeler only has the one school of magic, and it's one that isn't primary in rogue (really only seen in poisons, and in razorpetals in Un'Goro). You do have a point with swing turns though, I might look into changing it to be more like Bloodsail Deckhand, or Kindling Elemental.
Quote From <a href=
You shouldn't use the K&C watermark, since Spell Schools didn't exist back then. Otherwise, it's a very solid card.
Thank you for the feedback. It sucks that I should change the watermark, as I think it fits perfectly into K&C (with a kingsbane rogue in K&C, and with razorpetals in the same year). That being said, it has to be done, so I'll change it to a custom watermark.
I think Lien is too weak as is. If you don't have any razorpetals in your hand, Lien doesn't do anything. I have two possible suggestions:
Make the razorblooms into 2/2s, have the effect be permanent, transforming all razorpetals that were created and will be created this game into razorblooms.
Alternatively, buff Lien to a 2 mana 3/2, making her not a terrible play on her own.
Rokkar needs some kind of restriction. Compare it to making all the minions in your deck into dragons, or into murlocs. Nature doesn't have much synergy yet, but that's because it's only the first expansion having spell schools.
Fungal giant might be fine balance wise, just correct the typo in "…a minion survived damage…" (correction is bold).
Scavenging lasher is balanced - would definitely see play in poison rogue if it becomes a thing.
I lied when I said I'm not taking part in this. This card is intended to support poison rogue as well as razorpetal rogue. Besides the normal feedback, I'm also looking for a potentially better name, as I'm not a huge fan of the current one.
The fact that it is often useless/low value condemns it to the "I doubt this would be played much" pile. I might be wrong though, because silence is often run in the meta.
I really wouldn't call Sir Annoy-O a Halloween skin. It doesn't have any connection to it, besides being sold in a bundle at the time.
Ok, but where's Boulderfist Ogre? Jokes aside, this looks great! I could see these in the game.
Ok, but the problem is with it in no minion mage...
Frost warrior has peaked my interest - what do you all think it would look like?
That doesn't make sense - people always want better decks. Often, "good enough" is not good enough.
Kind of a shame, but makes sense.
Congratulations to Bananenparty and SilverWolf!
The same can be said about casual.
The first one is impossible to answer, as not even team 5 knows. As for the second one it probably depends entirely on warcraft lore. Other classes might have similar mechanics, but I doubt that other classes that don't get sigils in WoW would get them in Hearthstone.
The reason I put it at 1 mana is because of Sorcerer's Apprentice and Radiant Elemental. Those two cards are unrestricted in the types of cards they can discount, meanwhile Spore Channeler only has the one school of magic, and it's one that isn't primary in rogue (really only seen in poisons, and in razorpetals in Un'Goro). You do have a point with swing turns though, I might look into changing it to be more like Bloodsail Deckhand, or Kindling Elemental.
Thank you for the feedback. It sucks that I should change the watermark, as I think it fits perfectly into K&C (with a kingsbane rogue in K&C, and with razorpetals in the same year). That being said, it has to be done, so I'll change it to a custom watermark.
Feedback:
DestroyerR
Make the razorblooms into 2/2s, have the effect be permanent, transforming all razorpetals that were created and will be created this game into razorblooms.
Alternatively, buff Lien to a 2 mana 3/2, making her not a terrible play on her own.
cydonianknight
I like coated mushroom 2. It looks like a card that could be printed in my opinion.
shatterstar1998
Rokkar needs some kind of restriction. Compare it to making all the minions in your deck into dragons, or into murlocs. Nature doesn't have much synergy yet, but that's because it's only the first expansion having spell schools.
Fungal giant might be fine balance wise, just correct the typo in "…a minion survived damage…" (correction is bold).
Scavenging lasher is balanced - would definitely see play in poison rogue if it becomes a thing.
I'll give more feedback later.
I lied when I said I'm not taking part in this. This card is intended to support poison rogue as well as razorpetal rogue. Besides the normal feedback, I'm also looking for a potentially better name, as I'm not a huge fan of the current one.
Actually, it's run in Mech Handbuff Paladin, a deck that's often tier 1 / tier 2 in wild.
I'm not planning to participate in this, but here is a great piece of art you guys can use:
http://www.artofmtg.com/art/roots/
Do we have details on the Reddit giveaway?
I was looking through rogue secret cards, and I noticed these two cards:
https://outof.cards/hearthstone/cards/11257-shady-business
https://outof.cards/hearthstone/cards/11266-subtlety
I never saw these cards before, so I'm bringing it up here.
This might have been part of Book of Heroes, I didn't play through the new ones yet.
What happened to Guff's glasses?
The fact that it is often useless/low value condemns it to the "I doubt this would be played much" pile. I might be wrong though, because silence is often run in the meta.
So it wasn't a hunter card after all...
Considering anchorm4n mentioned Rotten Applebaum, I think they know.
Kazakus actually costs 4 as well...